Andi Dorfman told Josh Murray “You’re too good to be true”

Andi Dorfman told Josh Murray that he was “too good to be true” after he got down on one knee in the Dominican Republic and asked her to marry him on the Bachelorette finale. But now Life & Style has learned that Josh is no longer acting like the sweet, sensitive guy she fell for.


“Josh can be controlling and jealous,” an insider exclusively reveals in the new issue of Life & Style – on stands now. “He’s very insecure about the relationship, and even more so after watching everything unfold on TV and seeing Andi tell other guys she’s in love with them.”

Since Andi and Josh both live in Atlanta, they spend a lot of time together and according to the insider, any time apart is questioned by Josh. “She’s a fiercely independent person and loves going out with her friends,” the insider tells Life & Style. “At first, she thought his jealousy was cute, but now that they’re not hiding their relationship, he’s jealous all the time and I’m not sure how cute she’s finding it.”-LIFE & STYLE WEEKLY